Screw Pump Selection Guide - Type Selection and Sizing Criteria

Complete selection guide for screw pumps including single, twin, and triple screw type selection, application matching, and sizing criteria for Process Engineers.

API 676

Selection Decision Process

Step 1: Confirm PD Pump is Appropriate

Choose Positive Displacement (Screw) when:

ConditionWhy Screw Pump
Viscosity > 100 cStCentrifugal efficiency drops significantly
Constant flow requiredPD maintains flow regardless of pressure
Self-priming neededScrew pumps prime themselves
Low pulsation criticalScrew pumps have minimal pulsation
Shear-sensitive fluidGentle pumping action
Accurate meteringFlow proportional to speed
High pressure, low flowScrew pumps excel here

Choose Centrifugal instead when:

ConditionWhy Centrifugal
Viscosity < 100 cStHigher efficiency, lower cost
High flow (>500 m³/h)Broader range available
Variable flow neededSimple throttling control
Lower initial cost criticalCentrifugal costs less
Clean, low viscosity fluidStandard application

Step 2: Select Screw Pump Type

                      START


            ┌───────────────────────┐
            │ Fluid contains solids │
            │      or fibers?       │
            └───────────────────────┘
                   │         │
                  YES        NO
                   │         │
                   ▼         ▼
           ┌──────────┐   ┌───────────────────────┐
           │  SINGLE  │   │ Viscosity > 10,000 cSt│
           │  SCREW   │   └───────────────────────┘
           └──────────┘          │         │
                               YES        NO
                                │         │
                                ▼         ▼
                        ┌──────────┐   ┌───────────────────┐
                        │  SINGLE  │   │ Pressure > 100 bar│
                        │  SCREW   │   └───────────────────┘
                        └──────────┘          │         │
                                            YES        NO
                                             │         │
                                             ▼         ▼
                                     ┌──────────┐   ┌──────────┐
                                     │  TRIPLE  │   │   TWIN   │
                                     │  SCREW   │   │  SCREW   │
                                     └──────────┘   └──────────┘

Type Selection Matrix

Application-Based Selection

ApplicationViscosityPressureSolidsBest Type
Crude oil transfer100-5000 cSt< 30 barPossibleTwin
Bitumen handling10,000+ cSt< 20 barYesSingle
Lube oil system50-500 cSt10-100 barNoTwin/Triple
Hydraulic power30-100 cSt100-350 barNoTriple
Polymer transfer1000-50000 cSt< 20 barPossibleSingle
Fuel transfer2-20 cSt< 10 barNoTwin
Chemical processVariableVariableNoTwin
Sludge/wastewaterVariable< 20 barYesSingle
Food productsVariable< 20 barPossibleSingle

Performance-Based Selection

RequirementSingle ScrewTwin ScrewTriple Screw
Max viscosity1,000,000 cP1,000,000 cP*1,000 cSt
Max pressure48 bar300 bar350 bar
Max flow500 m³/h1,000 m³/h500 L/min
Solids handlingExcellentPoorNone
PulsationLow-MediumVery LowMinimal
Noise levelMediumLowLow
Self-primingExcellentGoodGood
CostLow-MediumMedium-HighHigh

*Special designs only

Sizing Criteria

Required Process Data

ParameterUnitWhy Needed
Flow ratem³/h or L/minPump size selection
Discharge pressurebarPressure rating, slip calculation
Suction pressurebarNPSH verification
Viscosity at operating tempcSt or cPType selection, speed
Viscosity at startupcSt or cPCold start capability
Fluid temperature°CMaterial selection, clearances
Fluid specific gravity-Power calculation
Solids content% or ppmType selection
Vapor pressurebarCavitation check

Viscosity Considerations

Critical: Viscosity changes with temperature!

Fluid TypeTypical Viscosity Change
Mineral oil-5 to -7% per °C increase
Synthetic oil-3 to -5% per °C increase
Polymers-10 to -15% per °C increase
Heavy crude-8 to -12% per °C increase

Design for worst case:

  • Sizing: Use viscosity at operating temperature
  • Starting: Check viscosity at ambient (cold) temperature
  • Motor: Size for maximum viscosity condition

Flow Rate Determination

Required Flow = Process Demand × (1 + Margin)

Typical Margins:
- Standard service: 10-15%
- Critical service: 20-25%
- Variable demand: Size for maximum

Pressure Determination

Required Pressure = System Pressure + Friction Loss + Safety Margin

Components:
- Static head (elevation)
- Vessel/equipment pressure
- Pipeline friction losses
- Control valve pressure drop
- Safety margin: +10-15%

Speed Selection

Speed vs Viscosity Guidelines

Viscosity RangeRecommended SpeedNotes
< 100 cStUp to 2800 RPMNear centrifugal speeds
100-500 cSt1400-2800 RPMStandard twin screw
500-2000 cSt500-1400 RPMReduced speed
2000-10,000 cSt200-500 RPMLow speed required
> 10,000 cSt50-200 RPMVery low speed

Speed Impact on Performance

Lower SpeedHigher Speed
✅ Better for high viscosity✅ Higher flow per pump size
✅ Lower slip (better efficiency)✅ Smaller pump footprint
✅ Longer bearing life❌ Higher slip
❌ Larger pump required❌ More wear
❌ Higher initial cost❌ Cavitation risk at high viscosity

NPSH Verification

NPSH Calculation

NPSHa = (P_suction - P_vapor) / (ρ × g) + H_static - H_friction

Where:
P_suction = Absolute pressure at suction source
P_vapor = Vapor pressure of fluid at temperature
ρ = Fluid density
g = Gravitational acceleration
H_static = Static head (positive if flooded)
H_friction = Suction line friction losses

NPSH Requirements for Screw Pumps

Pump TypeTypical NPSHrAdvantage
Single screw0.5-2 mLowest requirement
Twin screw1-3 mGood suction capability
Triple screw2-4 mHigher than others
Centrifugal3-8 mHighest requirement

NPSH Margin

NPSHa ≥ NPSHr × 1.5 (minimum)

For critical service: NPSHa ≥ NPSHr × 2.0

Material Selection

Standard Materials by Component

ComponentStandard MaterialUpgrade Options
CasingDuctile iron316 SS, Duplex, Ni-alloys
ScrewsChrome-plated steelHardened steel, Stellite
BearingsBronze, carbonPEEK, ceramic
Shaft sealsMechanical sealDouble seal, lip seal
O-ringsFKM (Viton)FFKM, PTFE

Material Selection by Service

ServiceCasingScrewsSeals
Mineral oilDuctile ironChrome steelFKM
Chemical316 SSHardened SSFFKM
Food grade316L SS316L SSEPDM/PTFE
Sour serviceNACE compliantNACE compliantFFKM
High temp (>150°C)Cast steelHardened alloyGraphite

Motor Sizing

Power Calculation

P_shaft = (Q × ΔP) / (600 × η)

Where:
P_shaft = Shaft power (kW)
Q = Flow rate (L/min)
ΔP = Differential pressure (bar)
η = Pump efficiency (typically 0.7-0.9)

Motor Selection

P_motor = P_shaft × Service Factor

Service Factors:
- Normal duty: 1.15
- Heavy duty: 1.25
- Variable viscosity: 1.30
- Cold start: Consider startup torque

Cold Start Considerations

ConditionAction Required
Cold viscosity > 2× operatingSoft start or VFD
Cold viscosity > 5× operatingPre-heating required
Cold viscosity > 10× operatingHeating + slow start

Vendor Selection Criteria

Technical Evaluation

CriterionWeightWhat to Verify
Flow/pressure capability25%Meets process requirements
Efficiency at duty point15%Compare actual curves
Material compatibility20%Wetted parts suitable
NPSH requirement10%Adequate margin
Bearing life (L10)10%≥ 15,000 hours
References10%Similar service experience
Delivery/support10%Schedule and service

Must-Have Requirements

  • Flow tolerance within ±3%
  • Pressure rating ≥ specified + 10%
  • NPSHr < NPSHa with margin
  • API 676 compliance (if specified)
  • Material certificates for wetted parts
  • Performance curves at operating viscosity
  • Bearing life calculation (L10 ≥ 15,000 hrs)

Quick Selection Reference

By Flow Rate

Flow RangeTypical Pump Size
< 10 L/minSmall twin/triple
10-100 L/minMedium twin/triple
100-1000 L/minLarge twin
> 1000 L/minMultiple pumps or single screw

By Viscosity

ViscosityPrimary ChoiceAlternative
1-100 cStConsider centrifugalTwin screw
100-1000 cStTwin screwTriple screw
1000-10,000 cStTwin screw (low speed)Single screw
> 10,000 cStSingle screwTwin screw (special)

By Pressure

Pressure RangePrimary Choice
< 20 barSingle or Twin
20-100 barTwin screw
100-200 barTwin screw (HP) or Triple
> 200 barTriple screw

Frequently Asked Questions

When should I choose a screw pump over centrifugal?
Choose screw pump when: viscosity >100 cSt, constant flow regardless of pressure needed, self-priming required, low pulsation critical, or handling shear-sensitive fluids. Centrifugal is better for high flow, low viscosity, and lower cost applications.
Which screw pump type should I select?
Single screw for very high viscosity (>10,000 cSt) or fluids with solids. Twin screw for general industrial service, moderate viscosity, and higher pressures. Triple screw for highest pressure and precision applications like hydraulics.
What viscosity range is suitable for screw pumps?
Screw pumps excel from 100 cSt to over 100,000 cSt. Below 100 cSt, centrifugal pumps may be more economical. Above 100 cSt, screw pump efficiency actually improves due to reduced slip.

📚References & Sources

Need Help Evaluating Vendor Proposals?

AutoTBE uses AI to analyze technical bids and generate comprehensive comparison reports in minutes.

Try AutoTBE Free